All Hail Caesar! (The salad that is!)

Caesar Salad My first Caesar salad was almost 10 years ago, when Webster took me to meet some of his old friends in Virginia Beach, VA. We visited with this couple for a little while and then he took me to the Isle of Capri, a hotel rooftop restaurant overlooking the beach. It was Fall, the wind was quite sharp and the beach was deserted. He suggested the she-crab soup and the Caesar salad.

The salad’s creation is generally attributed to restaurateur Caesar Cardini, an Italian immigrant who operated restaurants in Mexico and the United States. Cardini was living

in San Diego but also working in Tijuana where he avoided the restrictions of Prohibition. His daughter Rosa recounted that her father invented the dish when a Fourth of July 1924 rush depleted the kitchen’s supplies. Cardini made do with what he had, adding the dramatic flair of the table-side tossing “by the chef.”

And a table-side demonstration is what we enjoyed that night at the restaurant. The maitre ‘d wheeled a cart laden with ingredients to the table and began the process of creating a magnificent salad. The performance only enhanced the taste!

A few weeks later we were in New York City, wandering around midtown. I was starving. Webster suggested Il Menestrello, a small Italian place on East 50th St. It was mid-afternoon and we were nearly the only ones there. Again, the maitre ‘d wheeled a cart up to our table and proceeded to perform a ritual I have come to love. Two hours, a bottle of wine and some fabulous pasta later and I knew I was falling in love – with Webster as well as with Caesar! Thank goodness the salad was prepared before the bottle of wine was consumed for my mission, upon seeing that cart being wheeled to our table, was to capture every morsel of preparation technique and return home with the ability to recreate that masterpiece of gastronomic excellence in the comfort of our own home.  So, I watched as our attendant pounded the garlic into the heavy wooden bowl.  I salivated as he crushed the anchovies and mixed them into the garlic mash and when he noticed my eyes straining and my neck craning to examine the next step, he promptly explained that by pulverizing the garlic and the anchovies into the wooden bowl, the oils were embedded into the bowl and it delivered a depth of flavor that no material, other than wood, could deliver.  It seemed he knew he was educating me and was happy to do so.  He completed his course of study with me and I left that afternoon with a great desire to make our maitre ‘d proud for years to come.  Give a girl a Caesar salad and she will eat for the day but teach a girl to make that Caesar salad and the world will eat for years to come.  So, go make our maitre ‘d proud!


The Cast


2    cloves garlic
3    anchovies
1    egg yolk
2    tsp Dijon mustard
1    tsp Worcestershire sauce
1    tsp lemon juice
1 tsp red wine vinegar
1/4  cup Parmesan cheese,grated
1/3 cup extra virgin olive oil
2    heads romaine lettuce


1. Place the Garlic in a large wooden bowl.  With a muddler, pound the garlic into the bottom of the bowl.

Garlic Duly Pummeled!

Garlic Duly Pummeled!

Garlic in bowl

Garlic Ready to be Pummeled







2. Add the anchovies to the bowl with the garlic and pound the anchovies into the garlic with your muddler until a paste is formed.  Then drop the egg yolk on top of the paste and whisk to combine.

Add Anchovies

Here fishy fishy!

Whisk in Egg Yolk

In goes the egg yolk






3. Now it’s time to spice things up a bit.  So, let’s add the dijon mustard, the Worcestershire sauce, the lemon juice and the red wine vinegar.

Add Mustard and Worcestershire Sauce

Let’s add some flavor!

Add Lemon Juice

Lemon juice going in






Add the Red Wine Vinegar

A little acidity is in order


4.  Now, whisk the items in the bowl together.  As you whisk, add the Parmesan cheese.  Your concoction should begin to look like this…

All Parmesan Cheese

Add the Parmesan

More Whisking

It’s coming together!!!






5. As we prepare to introduce the main ingredient, extra virgin olive oil, keep in mind…slow and steady stream.  So, as you continue to whisk, sloooowly add the olive oil.  Not to be repetitive, but slow pour and steady whisk.  This creates that luscious creaminess that makes this salad a true Caesar!




6.  Your dressing is complete and now for the grand finale…drum roll, please!  Introduce your crisp Romaine lettuce to your creamy concoction and toss about with salad tongs.

Add Romaine

The Romaine arrives


Tossing about










7.  At this point, you can serve your salad as it is or you may choose to add a few croutons and maybe some crispy chopped bacon.  In the past, I have topped my salad with single fried oysters or fried shrimp or pan seared scallops.  If you choose to use it as a side dish, it pairs nicely with any Italian entree and we have found it to be quite a compliment to crab cakes or oyster stew.

This time we opted for the simple Caesar salad.

So, if my Salad Professor aka Maitre ‘D is tuning in to this post…I hope I’ve made you proud!

Caesar Salad


About The Kitchen Island

Dedicated to the art of cooking simply and tastefully.
This entry was posted in Salads, Side Dishes, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to All Hail Caesar! (The salad that is!)

  1. Kevin Murphy says:

    Unable to locate a muddler in our kitchen (or anywhere else in our 10 X 50) we thought we were up the creek, but before feeding the lettuce to the pigs we picked up and old 16 oz. framing hammer and gave it a try. Smashed the bowl to bits, but did a job on the garlic.

    You may want to pass on this suggestion to your readers.

  2. Janice Bennet says:

    Ummy! I can attest to this being delicious. The Matriarch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s